Democratic lawmakers demand halt to Trump administration's ER patient data collection program

Democratic lawmakers are demanding that the Trump administration halt a Consumer Product Safety Commission program collecting identifiable emergency room records. The NEISS-R program, supported by a $15.9 million contract with Konza Health, pressures hospitals to share data on over 10,000 conditions. Despite initial threats of information-blocking penalties, the agency backtracked following hospital pushback, claiming the program remains voluntary.

CPSC emergency data collection

• ▪The Consumer Product Safety Commission launched a surveillance program, rebranded as NEISS-R, to collect personally identifiable health data of Americans visiting emergency departments
• ▪The Consumer Product Safety Commission contracted Kansas-based Konza Health under a five-year agreement worth up to $15.9 million to analyze the collected emergency department records

Democratic lawmakers suspension demand

• ▪Democratic lawmakers, including Senator Ed Markey, Senator Richard Blumenthal, Representative Jan Schakowsky, and Senator Ron Wyden, sent a letter demanding the Consumer Product Safety Commission immediately suspend its emergency department data collection program
• ▪The Democratic lawmakers' letter to Consumer Product Safety Commission acting Chairman Peter Feldman requested an official response to their demands by September 18, 2026

Hospital coercion tactics

• ▪Consumer Product Safety Commission chief data officer Elizabeth Puchek and Konza Health representatives told hospital executives that participation in the NEISS-R program was mandatory, threatening penalties for unlawful information blocking
• ▪The Consumer Product Safety Commission backtracked on its mandatory stance by removing information-blocking penalty threats from its website, and acting Chairman Peter Feldman stated the program would remain voluntary
• ▪The American Hospital Association sent a letter in August 2026 expressing concern and confusion over the scope of patient information demanded by the Consumer Product Safety Commission

Agency mission scope expansion

• ▪The Consumer Product Safety Commission's historical National Electronic Injury Surveillance System was voluntary and requested patients' identifiable information in fewer than 1% of cases
• ▪The Consumer Product Safety Commission instructed hospitals to share detailed patient information for more than 10,000 types of injuries or conditions, including vaccine reactions, suicide attempts, and stingray stabs

Trump health data acquisition

• ▪The Office of Personnel Management and Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. have launched separate broad acquisitions of sensitive medical records during Donald Trump's second presidential term
• ▪Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. deputized at least one private organization to collect medical records to support his studies on vaccines and autism

Debatable claims

• ▪The CPSC should collect patient data only for injuries involving consumer products
• ▪The CPSC should suspend its NEISS-R patient data collection program
• ▪Hospital participation in the CPSC's NEISS-R program should be mandatory

2 sources