UnitedHealthcare and physician staffing company TeamHealth have settled a 2021 lawsuit in which the insurer accused TeamHealth of deliberately upcoding emergency department claims to secure $100 million in overpayments since 2016. The confidential settlement led to a voluntary dismissal with prejudice on September 24, 2026. Separately, UnitedHealthcare named 15-year company veteran Bobby Hunter as its new president on September 28, 2026, to drive its modernization agenda.
Settlement of the upcoding lawsuit
- ▪The settlement terms between UnitedHealthcare and TeamHealth remain confidential, and the lawsuit was voluntarily dismissed with prejudice following an agreement in principle reached on August 11, 2026.
- ▪UnitedHealthcare and TeamHealth settled a lawsuit on September 24, 2026, in Tennessee federal court, resolving allegations that the physician staffing company upcoded emergency department claims.
Allegations against TeamHealth
- ▪UnitedHealthcare filed the lawsuit against TeamHealth in October 2021, alleging that TeamHealth deliberately upcoded emergency department claims to induce overpayments of approximately $100 million since 2016.
- ▪UnitedHealthcare's review of TeamHealth claims found that 62% of emergency department claims billed under the two highest-paying codes, CPT codes 99285 and 99284, were unsupported by medical records.
Concerns over AI-Assisted coding
- ▪An analysis by the Blue Cross Blue Shield Association found that artificial intelligence-assisted hospital claims added $942 million in healthcare costs over two years due to complex condition listings.
- ▪Blue Cross Blue Shield Association Senior Vice President Luke Chalker stated that the conflict over AI-assisted medical coding is a one-sided bloodbath costing insurers money.
Leadership changes at UnitedHealthcare
- ▪Bobby Hunter, also referred to as Robert Hunter, was named president of UnitedHealthcare on September 28, 2026, after previously serving as the company's CEO of government programs.
- ▪UnitedHealth Group confirmed that Tim Noel will continue to serve as the chief executive of UnitedHealthcare following Bobby Hunter's appointment as president.
Debatable claims
- ▪AI-assisted medical coding does more harm than good
- ▪Confidential settlements in healthcare billing disputes do more harm than good
- ▪UnitedHealthcare was justified in suing TeamHealth over alleged upcoding
- ▪Physician staffing companies bear primary responsibility for rising emergency department costs
Story comments
Loading comments…