The Fifth Circuit, ruling en banc in State of Texas v. Blanche (No. 24-10386), held that House proxy voting during COVID-19 violated the Constitution's Quorum Clause, invalidating the House's passage of the $1.7 trillion fiscal year 2023 spending bill. The ruling targets the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act and is expected to be appealed to the US Supreme Court.
Fifth Circuit proxy voting ruling
- ▪A prior Fifth Circuit panel had found that Congress acted within its authority when creating the proxy voting rule, but that panel decision was vacated when the full Fifth Circuit agreed to take up the case
- ▪Judge Cory Wilson, a Donald Trump appointee, wrote the majority opinion in the Fifth Circuit's en banc proxy voting ruling
- ▪Other federal courts rejected challenges to House proxy voting at the time it was adopted, finding the cases were foreclosed by the US Constitution's Speech or Debate Clause
- ▪The full Fifth Circuit en banc court ruled that remote proxy voting by the US House of Representatives during the Covid-19 pandemic violated the US Constitution
- ▪The Fifth Circuit's en banc proxy voting ruling applies specifically to Texas' challenge to a federal law requiring accommodations be offered to pregnant employees
Constitutional quorum clause arguments
- ▪Judge Cory Wilson's majority opinion stated that proxy presence does not count for quorum purposes under the Constitution's Quorum Clause
- ▪Judge Cory Wilson's majority opinion held that the text, context, original understanding, and unbroken historical application of the Constitution's Quorum Clause all indicate that Members of Congress must be physically present for quorum purposes
- ▪The Constitution's Quorum Clause grants Congress the power to compel the attendance of absent members
- ▪Only the US House of Representatives used proxy voting during the Covid-19 pandemic; senators kept voting in person
Pregnant Workers Fairness Act challenge
- ▪The Pregnant Workers Fairness Act was enacted as part of the fiscal year 2023 spending package
- ▪US District Judge James 'Wes' Hendrix ruled in favor of Texas' challenge to the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act in 2024
- ▪The case challenging the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act is State of Texas v. Blanche, 5th Cir. en banc, No. 24-10386
Dissent scope concerns
- ▪Judge James Graves Jr. questioned in his dissent why the ruling's effect should be limited to one provision of the fiscal year 2023 spending package if the entirety of the statute was unconstitutionally passed
- ▪Judge James Graves Jr., a Barack Obama appointee, dissented from the Fifth Circuit's en banc proxy voting ruling
Supreme Court appeal prospects
- ▪A Democrat won the Texas attorney general race, meaning Republicans will no longer control the Texas attorney general's office starting in January 2027
- ▪The Fifth Circuit's en banc proxy voting ruling could lead to additional challenges to the fiscal year 2023 spending package beyond the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act
- ▪The Fifth Circuit's en banc proxy voting ruling is expected to be appealed to the US Supreme Court
Story comments
Loading comments…