Candace Owens debates Andrew Wilson over unproven Israel theory in Charlie Kirk assassination

During a highly publicized debate on the PBD Podcast, conservative commentator Candace Owens conceded to online debater Andrew Wilson that she lacks direct evidence linking Israel to the September 10, 2025, assassination of Turning Point USA founder Charlie Kirk. While Owens continues to promote theories of an "Israeli angle" and alleged foreign cellphones near the Utah Valley University shooting, law enforcement officials maintain that 23-year-old Tyler Robinson is the sole suspect charged in the murder, with no evidence of foreign involvement.

Owens-Wilson debate over Kirk assassination

• ▪The PBD Podcast debate episode featuring Candace Owens and Andrew Wilson surpassed 3.1 million views on X within 24 hours of its release.
• ▪Andrew Wilson offered Candace Owens up to $300,000 to publicly debate her claims, a figure Owens later proposed raising to $500,000.
• ▪Candace Owens and Andrew Wilson debated on the PBD Podcast, moderated by Patrick Bet-David, regarding Owens' unproven theories about the assassination of Charlie Kirk.

Unproven Israel involvement theory

• ▪Charlie Kirk's widow, Erika Kirk, publicly urged Candace Owens during a December 10, 2025, Fox News appearance to stop spreading theories about her husband's death.
• ▪Candace Owens repeated an unsubstantiated claim that 12 Israeli-registered cellphones were detected near the Utah Valley University shooting scene, a claim unconfirmed by law enforcement.
• ▪Former National Counterterrorism Center Director Joe Kent suggested in March 2026 that Charlie Kirk's death deserved further scrutiny, amid an FBI investigation into Kent for allegedly leaking classified material.
• ▪Candace Owens conceded during the debate with Andrew Wilson that she has no direct evidence showing Israel was involved on the ground in the killing of Charlie Kirk.

Campus free speech legal protections

• ▪Six days after Charlie Kirk's death, then-Attorney General Pam Bondi declared the government would target individuals for hate speech, a statement she later walked back.
• ▪Nearly half of U.S. states have passed versions of the Forming Open and Robust University Minds Act to ban campus free speech zones and viewpoint discrimination.

Student tolerance for speaker violence

• ▪A FIRE survey of nearly 70,000 students at 257 institutions found that 1 in 3 American college students express some tolerance for using violence to stop a campus speaker.
• ▪The FIRE College Free Speech Rankings indicated that the decline in support for free speech was the sharpest among conservative students.

Kirk assassination investigation status

• ▪Tyler Robinson, 23, remains the sole suspect charged with aggravated murder in the September 10, 2025, shooting of Charlie Kirk at Utah Valley University.
• ▪No law enforcement agency or prosecutor has presented evidence of foreign involvement in the assassination of Charlie Kirk.

3 sources