Justice Department asks court to reinstate criminal charges against Kilmar Abrego Garcia

The U.S. Department of Justice has appealed to the 6th Circuit Court of Appeals to reinstate human smuggling charges against Kilmar Abrego Garcia. The charges, stemming from a 2022 Tennessee traffic stop, were dismissed in May 2026 by U.S. District Judge Waverly David Crenshaw Jr., who ruled the prosecution was a vindictive retaliation for Abrego Garcia successfully challenging his wrongful 2025 deportation. The DOJ denies any vindictive motive, asserting career prosecutors acted on clear evidence, while Abrego Garcia's defense team maintains the case was a politically motivated White House vendetta.

DOJ appeal to reinstate charges

• ▪The Department of Justice argued in its August 17, 2026, filing that the district court's dismissal of the indictment marks an unwarranted intrusion into the executive branch's powers.
• ▪The U.S. Department of Justice filed an appeal on August 17, 2026, asking the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 6th Circuit to reinstate human smuggling charges against Kilmar Abrego Garcia.
• ▪Attorneys representing Kilmar Abrego Garcia called the Department of Justice's appeal flat wrong and asserted that the prosecution was initiated vindictively on instructions from the White House.

2022 Tennessee traffic stop evidence

• ▪The Department of Justice's brief details text messages between Kilmar Abrego Garcia and an unidentified minor witness, whom he repeatedly invited to join him on his trips.
• ▪The human smuggling charges against Kilmar Abrego Garcia stem from a November 2022 traffic stop in Tennessee, where state Highway Patrol found him transporting multiple passengers without luggage.
• ▪The Department of Justice's appellate brief states that Kilmar Abrego Garcia was driving a vehicle registered to convicted human smuggler Jose Hernandez Reyes during the November 2022 traffic stop.
• ▪Jose Hernandez Reyes told investigators that Kilmar Abrego Garcia worked as a driver in his smuggling operation and had saved Abrego Garcia's contact in his phone as chauffeur.

Abrego Garcia wrongful deportation

• ▪A federal Supreme Court order forced the Trump administration to return Kilmar Abrego Garcia to the United States in June 2025, ruling his deportation was wrongful.
• ▪Kilmar Abrego Garcia was deported to El Salvador in March 2025, where he was sent to the Cecot anti-terrorism mega-prison.
• ▪Kilmar Abrego Garcia is fighting the Trump administration's ongoing efforts to deport him to Liberia in a separate federal court case in Maryland.

Vindictive prosecution ruling

• ▪Judge Waverly David Crenshaw Jr. noted that the case was tainted by sustained oversight from top officials, including communications between Middle District of Tennessee U.S. Attorney Rob McGuire and Associate Deputy Attorney General Aakash Singh.
• ▪Judge Waverly David Crenshaw Jr. ruled that there was enough evidence of presumptive vindictiveness, noting the Department of Homeland Security waited over two years to investigate the 2022 traffic stop.
• ▪U.S. District Judge Waverly David Crenshaw Jr. dismissed the criminal indictment against Kilmar Abrego Garcia in May 2026, finding the prosecution was vindictive in nature.

Attorney General Todd Blanche statements

• ▪The Department of Justice argued in its August 17, 2026, brief that Attorney General Todd Blanche's statements demonstrated a legitimate motive to protect the public and confirm prior assertions of criminal activity.
• ▪The Department of Justice argued that even if Attorney General Todd Blanche's statements showed animus, they were irrelevant because the charges were brought by then-Acting U.S. Attorney Rob McGuire.
• ▪Judge Waverly David Crenshaw Jr. found that public statements by Attorney General Todd Blanche, who was a deputy at the time, suggested the Justice Department targeted Kilmar Abrego Garcia for winning his deportation case.

5 sources